Quick Search Tags
Smith's Research & Gradings
August 3, 2020

Smith's Research & Gradings

New York Is No "Donor State"

New York Is No "Donor State"

In  truth,  high-tax  blue  states  are  net  "receivers"  of federal funds, New York foremost among them, according to Matthew Schoenfeld, a Chicago-based municipal bond portfolio manager.

He gored one of the sacred cows of  New Yorkers (and many municipal analysts). What's more, Mr. Schoenfeld did it publicly — in the Wall Street Journal's Opinion Page on July 22, 2020. Governor Andrew  Cuomo,  (D.NY)  has  repeatedly flouted a list of "donor states" topped by New York, which "gives" $29 bln. a year more than it "got" from 2015 through 2018. The source of the Governor's claim is the Rockefeller Institute's "Giving or Getting" which was published in 2017.

Mr. Schoenfeld wrote, "It isn't so simple. A food stamp isn't the same as a serviceman's paycheck. The former can be characterized as a federal subsidy — a gift in Mr. Cuomo's parlance — while the latter cannot. The Rockefeller report treats both as gifts, distorting who gets what.

"Texas is home to nearly 219,000 military personnel, New York 60,000. It's no surprise federal defense-related ex- penditures in Texas dwarfed those in New York. From this the Rockefeller report implies Texas got $51 bln. more than New York — for the privilege of defending the whole country." That doesn't square. If the DOD's spending is used to allocate the "value of the defense provided by the federal government by population" in 2018, New York got $2 bln. more than it gave.

What's  more  Mr.  Schoenfeld's  analysis  shows  how blue  states  disproportionately  reap  the  benefits  of  federal subsidization  for  municipal  debt issuance.   Based  on  the Congressional Budget Office 2018 estimate, New York State got more than $9 bln. than it received (bringing the total got to $11 bln.) Back out the $2 bln. in social security payments that  New York  State  avoids  because  its  retirees  move  to warmer climates, and the "get" grows to $13 bln.

Take notice

Stay on top of the latest global news that can impact your investment strategy.

Negative Event Risk (-1)

Here Comes the Sun

Smith's is issuing an Event Risk for Solar Flares (+1) The Solar Cycle 25 reached its lowest level in 2020 and it has started climbing higher in 2021. Forecasts predict the Solar 25 Cycle will peak in 2025.

Clean Energy Needs Reliability Requirement

Clean energy needs to include reliability requirement as new technology advances. Transformation of the energy mix used in electricity generation globally has been focused on development of renewable sources of energy such as wind and solar, but the major stumbling block has remained reliability.

Big Bucks for Infrastructure

The $1.2 trillion Bipartisan Infrastructure Framework, which has garnered the support of the Biden Administration, calls for billions in funding for traditional infrastructure.

Subscribe Today to unlock insights that could impact you tomorrow!

With your monthly or yearly Subscription you will unlock online articles and have the ability to download the full PDF files for the publication.
$79.95 / Per Month
$850 / Year (Save 30%)
* Discounted Rates for Issuers and Governmental Entities

Smith's Research & Gradings focuses on the people, sectors and news that matter the most to you. Smith's analysis is an indispensable part of Wall Street and the world's capital markets. Our approach was inspired by the need for a consistent analytical approach across all asset classes.

$79.50 / Per Month
$850 / Year (Save 30%)
* Discounted Rates for Issuers and Governmental Entities

Let a subscription to The Global Economic Doctor provide you with access to sovereign news, analysis and insights. Concise and powerful, the Global Economic Doctor spans the globe, giving you a read on how today’s market developments and key players are impacting your business around the planet.